Resume Optimizer vs Manual ATS Check

Manual ATS checking can be accurate, but it’s slow. Optimizers win when you’re applying to multiple roles because they compress hours of tailoring into minutes.

Run A Free ATS Check →
Learn ATS Formatting Rules →

Best For / Not Great For

Manual best for:

  • One specific role

  • People who enjoy detailed editing

  • Deep control over every word

Manual not great for:

  • High-volume applications

  • Quick iteration

  • Consistency over time

Optimizer best for:

  • Speed + repeatability

  • Job-specific keyword alignment

  • Fast bullet rewriting

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Speed: Optimizer wins

Control: Manual wins

Consistency: Optimizer wins

Cost: depends (time vs money)

Scaling across job posts: Optimizer wins

If you go manual, do this

  1. Use ATS Formatting Rules

  2. Build a keyword list from the job post

  3. Place keywords in Skills + bullets

  4. Run Fit Check to validate parsing

FAQ

How long should manual tailoring take?

What’s the best manual keyword method?

Can manual beat tools?

What’s the biggest manual mistake?

PDF or DOCX?

Start with Fit Check → then optimize faster

Run Fit Check to spot gaps, then optimize toward your role with Perfect Match.

Check My Resume
Optimize My Resume